Not, it's not about the comic/manga, or the anime…
It's about the real human version of the movies,
Movie 1, 2 to 3,
Movie 1, 2 - Shun Oguri, and whoever there…
Movie 3 - Mizobata Junpei and whoever there…
Well… I've to say, say, say, cos,
After I saw movie 3, that's it…
I was like… arrgh…
It's not like I dislike mizobata junpei, or whatever, but then,
It's also not like shun oguri's the best person to portray shinichi,
BUT, at least, shun oguri's tall, or… rather long… vertically, somehow, resemble how it is in the manga…
I don't know how the production team select the so-called "right actor/actress" to portray these shows… adaptation from manga, especially those famous ones…
But when it gets to movie 3, ie. mizobata junpei,
That's it…
Like I said, it's not like I dislike him,
I like him, a nice little young policeman in Shinzanmono,
But then, when I watched movie 3, I thought, something wrong…
That's it, he's SHORT… maybe in real life he's not THAT short, but then, after seeing shun oguri, seeing him, as shinichi, it's a HUGE contrast…
And of course, I don't even wanna bother to mention about whoever who portrays Mori Ran,
See… I actually like the Mori Ran in the comic,
Clean and clear, sweet and understanding, straightforward, no sappy sappy…
But then, 2 generations, irregardless it's Kurokawa Tomoka, or Kutsuna Shiori…
My goodness~~
Both I feel like giving them a slap, in fact, I dislike kurokawa tomoka more, for some reason, just like Suzuki Anne, for some reason, I think both of them, have such a common look as to be a japanese actress… yes, may sounds a little bit harsh, but then, seriously… their look is just sooooooooooo "not appetizing"…
On the other hand,
I thought, from movie 1-3,
Both Jinnai Takanori who portrays the biggest moron in the story, ie. Mori Kogoro, and the inspector, by Ibu Masato, are pretty close to how the comic is… especially Jinnai Takanori… ^_^
Anyway… just some of my opinion…
There you go,
1st generation,
Shun Oguri and Kurokawa Tomoka,
2nd generation, (goodness!)